Actions are (judged) by motives (niyyah)

Background

     This hadith was said by the Prophet, sallallahu 'alayhi wasallam, at the time when a man emigrated

from Makkah to Madinah during the Hijrah for the sake of marrying someone and not for the

sake of Islam.

It is considered to be one of the greatest hadiths in Islam. Al-Imam al-Shafie said: This Hadith is one third of the knowledge of Islam; related to about 70 topics of Fiqh.

 

        Al-Imam Ahmad (with reference to al-Imam al-Shafie's statement) said: Islam is based on three

fundamentals (all are among the 40 hadiths ):

i. Hadith 1: which is stated above.

ii. Hadith 5: "Whosoever introduces into this affair of ours (i.e. Islam) something that does

not belong to it, it is to be rejected."

iii. Hadith 6: "Truly, what is lawful is evident, and what is unlawful is evident, and in

between the two are matters which are doubtful which many people do not know…”

 

       These three hadiths are agreed upon by Al-Bukhari and Muslim. These hadiths can be seen as three criteria to help Muslims evaluate and judge what they do and say "as an ibadah" in their daily life:

i. Hadith 1 - To evaluate and judge our internal actions (actions of the heart).

ii. Hadith 5 - To evaluate and judge our external actions (actions of the limbs).

iii. Hadith 6 - To evaluate and judge our dealings "mu'amalat" (interaction between people).

 

       Niyyah (intention) has two meanings:

i. The intention before an ibadah (e.g. prayer)

ii. The willingness

The second meaning (ii.) is what is meant in this hadith.

 

    Lessons

         The Prophet, sallallahu 'alayhi wasallam, starts the hadith with the principle ("Actions are judged by intentions") and then gives three examples. This is the methodology of the Prophet, sallallahu

'alayhi wasallam. The examples help illustrate the principle so that it is easier for people to

understand and they can apply the principle to other similar situations. The three examples consist of one of good intention (migration for the sake of Allah and His Messenger) and two of bad intentions (migration for the sake of worldly gains or for marriage).

 

         This hadith emphasizes ikhlas (sincerity - to be truthful and honest to Allah alone, performing an

act solely for Allah's sake whereby no other witness except Allah is sought). Ikhlas is one of the

conditions of accepting good deeds. The other condition is that the actions must be done in

accordance with the Shariah as it will be explained in the fifth hadith.

This can be seen in the shahadah:  "I bear witness that there is no god but Allah" is the ikhlas - ensuring that we do thing for the sake of Allah and Allah alone.

"I bear witness that Mohammed is the Messenger of Allah" - the Sunnah is the manifestation of the Quran - the Prophet, sallallahu 'alayhi wasallam, is our example, our best model to follow. Following his Sunnah in our ibadah, Akhlaq (ethics), and Muamalat (dealings) ensures that we are acting in accordance with the Shariah.

 

      Thus, the shahadah shows us the conditions for accepting a deed or performing an action: (a) it

should be for the sake of Allah because He is the only One we worship, and (b) it should be in accordance with the Shariah.

 

      To achieve ikhlas, we have to avoid shirk (associating others with Allah, which causes insincerity). Al-Imam al-Harawi said the root cause for insincerity (or shirk) is self-desire (alhawa).

Therefore no action should be done because of self-desire. Imam al-Harawi states that there are 7 types of self-desires:-

i. To make oneself appear good in the hearts of others

ii. To seek the praises of others

iii. To avoid being blamed by others

iv. To seek the glorification of others

v. To seek the wealth/money of others

vi. To seek the services or love of others

vii. To seek the help of others for oneself

 

 Ways to obtain ikhlas:

·         Do righteous deeds - the more good deeds we do and hence get closer to Allah, the

·         more sincere we will be.

·         Before we do any deed we should firstly seek knowledge (ilm) - our actions/deeds should

·         be guided by knowledge so that we do them in accordance to the Shariah.

·         Do not give false impressions - do not make others believe that an action we did was

·         good when it was not.

·         Al-Imam Ahmad said: Before you do anything, check your intention (niyyah) - ask

·         yourself before performing an action: "Is it for the sake of Allah?"

 

     Ibnu al-Qayyim says: Any action we do is subject to three defects:

i. Being conscious that others are observing our actions

ii. Seeking a return (benefit/reward) for the action

iii. Being satisfied with the action

 

Examples:

o   If we go to the masjid for the salah and we are early, arriving before the Imam and finding a place in the first saff, we should not be proud of ourselves and think of ourselves being better than others. We should praise Allah for enabling us to go to the masjid and for being able to perform the salah without any difficulties.

o   After every salah, we should tell ourselves that we could have performed it better and try to improve in our next salah.

 

          What happens if we were to change our niyyah while performing an action? Ibn Rajab says

according to the ulama' if the niyyah at the end of the action matches the beginning (i.e. doing the

action for the sake of Allah), then any changes in the middle of the action will be forgiven or

does not matter, insha Allah. However, if the niyyah at the end does not match the beginning, i.e. we do the action for other than the sake of Allah, then we must repent (taubah).

 

There are four things that contradict ikhlas:

i. Ma'siat - committing sins - this will weaken our ikhlas

ii. Shirk - associating others with Allah

iii. Riya' - performing an ibadah with the intention of showing off to others

iv. Nifaq - hypocrisy

          Even though we must always make sure that our actions do not deviate from ikhlas, there are actions, which are automatically considered that of good intentions. For example, seeking knowledge in Islam, helping the community, doing da'wah, etc.

 

Some rulings (ahkam) which scholars derived from this hadith:

A.      When people 'swear by Allah' by saying "Wallahi" every now and then, their intention is not that they actually swear by Allah. They say it simply out of habit - it readily rolls off  their tongue. Hence, it is harmless. However a Muslim should do his/her best to minimize it.

B.      When someone is asked to give an oath, what is judged is his intention when he gives the oath.

C.      There can be a combination of intentions between performing an ibadah and teaching others - we perform an ibadah for the sake of Allah, but we also do it with the intention of teaching others. e.g. when the Prophet, sallallahu 'alayhi wasallam, performed the Hajj, he did it for the sake of Allah as well as for teaching the Sahabah (his companions, may Allah be pleased with them all).

D.      A man may go through the process of divorcing his wife, verbally or in court, but it is his intention which counts.

 

E.       What could be seen as ghibah (backbiting - talking bad, but true, things about a person behind his back) could simply be a joke or a dua. If someone talks b